Torchwood: Miracle Day, Episode 4

(Index to all Torchwood posts here.)

It continues.

Plot:

So, Torchwood and friends are on the run and trying to dig up info on PhiCorp, the Über Eval drug company that may have orchestrated Miracle Day. They’re doing pretty well on the info front, but they’re doing lousy at the lying low. Esther actually drops by her sister’s and reports her to social services as an unfit mother. Gwen wanders around in the bright sunshine on her phone calling Rhys. And, having chastised Esther and Gwen, Rex shoots off to have an angsty-lack-of-reconciliation with his dad (and steal some of the painkillers his dad happens to be stock-piling). Unsurprisingly, they pick up a suspicious dude with a telephoto lens.

Torchwood learn how to break into a PhiCorp databank by obtaining the fingerprints, vocal patterns, and retinal image of a top scientist. Their tail does the same, in less humane ways, and lies in wait for them.

Meanwhile, a new News Star is on the rise, as Tea Party darling Ellis Hartley Monroe steals the limelight from Oswald Danes with her ‘Dead is Dead’ campaign, arguing that those who have died-but-not-died should not have equal rights to the properly ‘living’. At the same time, hospitals are persuaded to shove their emergency cases off to one side in a woefully under-equipped ‘plague-ship’ style hospital. Oswald steals the stage back by entering the disease-ridden building, making a speech, and holding a baby.

How was it?

I don’t know. I want to be more blown away by it than I am. I think the biggest problem is that, having started the series with an ass-kicking bang, Torchwood and friends are continuing to be disappointingly rubbish. I know it’s what keeps the plot going, but I can’t help but feel like there ought to be a Better Way. Also, much as I like seeing mental illness explored, there seems to be a conveniently unlikely amount of close-relatives-with-extreme-paranoia running around. It’s not entirely clear to me exactly what sort of mental illness these people suffer from, and at the moment it just all seems like a push towards heightened melodrama that’s hardly needed in the context of everything else that’s going down. It makes any discussion connected with these things feel like a throw-away-convenience.

Some elements of the plot are still working quite well, but I sort of feel uncomfortably unbalanced between something hard-hitting and clever and something surface level and pulpish. Where the opening couple of episodes really got the mix of old Torchwood fun and Children of Earth grimness right, it’s feeling more like an uncomfortable see-saw to me at the moment.

I don’t know how I feel about the Oswald Danes plot. It’s either brilliant or awful. I don’t like it. I’m deeply, deeply uncomfortable with how easily people seem to be swayed into forgiving him and even worshiping him. They had a child molester hold a baby for Christ’s sake! I know we’re meant to be all ‘isn’t public opinion fickle’, but I’m not convinced it is as fickle on issues like this as is being portrayed. People really, really don’t like child molesters. Yes, one or two people stand up and say it’s sick and they see through him, but I’m fairly convinced there would be a lot more. People would have snatched that baby right out of his arms once they realised who he was, charisma or no charisma. And, frankly, despite how much I usually adore him as an actor, I’m just not finding Bill Pullman’s performance that compelling.

What is interesting is his relationship with his PR lady. I liked the reveal that she is thoroughly disgusted by him, but she’s doing her job anyway. There are a couple of really nice moments, like when Vera tells Jilly that the media circus and Jilly’s excitement about it is disgusting, and Jilly delightedly responds ‘I know’ – a very nice piece of acting from Laura Ambrose. I also really loved the moment in Oswald’s hotel room as he crouches quietly by his mini-bar, cracking bottle after bottle just to hear the carbonated hiss we presume he’s been denied all these years. But overall, I’m just not sure. Mostly I feel like I’m being poked to talk about Oswald’s story because ‘gosh it’s so edgy’, but instead it feels overblown and implausible in a way that cheapens the edge. I am torn on this one, but it shouldn’t be mistaken for the sort of story that’s good because it sets your emotions and intuitions at war. This is no Dexter. Rather, sometimes it verges on something genuinely interesting, whilst at other times its crass and unbelievable.

In a similar way, bringing in a Tea Party Sarah-Palin-alike figure is in some ways quite daring and a nice piece of dry wit. But she’s introduced and thrown away in one episode, fitting in with my feeling that there are a lot of interesting ideas here, but they’re just being thrown in for colour rather than being really explored.

Perhaps I wouldn’t mind so much if the Torchwood focused stories were stronger. Credit must be given for Eve Myles’s consistently strong performance and the continuing believable emotion she brings to her familial relationships. However, the plot with her father being shipped away was so obvious it just bored me, rather than heightening the tension.

Still, I remain interested in seeing where it goes. The Jack plot is really intriguing, and I thought the bit where the hitman won’t kill him because he’s the last mortal man is a nice touch even if it’s also a fudge to explain why we get to keep our leading man when really he ought to have been killed. Keep it up, Torchwood, I’m still with you, but I’d like to see just a little bit more competence resurfacing soon.

Advertisements

About Serenity Womble

I'm a writer of science fiction and fantasy short stories, as well as many, many unfinished novels. I review things of a generally speculative nature. This is my blog for writing and reviewing.
This entry was posted in Review, Torchwood and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Torchwood: Miracle Day, Episode 4

  1. Anne Lyle says:

    I agree – Esther has a severe case of TSTL Syndrome (Too Stupid To Live), and the rest of the team aren’t much better. John Shiban is credited as writer, but someone must be planning the overall arc, and surely that must be RTD.

    Too be far to the Danes plot, we don’t see that much of public reaction – it’s mostly the media’s view we get, and we know full well *their* moral turpitude. And the people in the hospital are so worn down with sickness and being treated like scum that even a moment’s kindness (albeit totally faked kindness) overrides their opinion of Danes as a person, at least temporarily. Also, Pullman’s performance is not helped by the immobility of his face – I don’t know if he’s had a stroke, other health issues or just too much botox!

    • What frustrates me with Esther was that she started out SO AWESOME. She hunted down Torchwood by sensibly looking in related files and actually FINDING something that couldn’t be wiped by Jack’s FUTURE gadget. And now she’s… useless. And she doesn’t even get to remember that time when she was awesome.

      I know what you mean about the media, but the media also has a REAL hatred for paedophiles – not least because they know it’s something everyone can get together and buy papers/watch news on. Similarly, although some of the sick can certainly be excused by not knowing who he is, it’s part of the set-up that he’s been everywhere – more would recognise him, and even if only one old man did… any old man I’ve known would have jumped him to get that baby out of his arms. Possibly unsuccessfully, but enough to significantly impede his speechifying. It just desn’t sit… well.

      Shame about Bill Pullman. He’s not that old – either for botox or a stroke – he’s just hamming it up, as far as I can tell. I suspect he’s getting some direction in that regard, and the script certainly doesn’t help, but… he works better as a romantic lead, what can I say. (Gets out While You Were Sleeping and puts fingers in ears.)

  2. While I’m not actually following the Torchwood, I will just say that Bill Pullman is the best president America’s ever had, bar none.

    • 😀 LOL. I would agree, but I thin Bartlett gives him a run for his money. Except they’re almost the same man in my mind. Pullman is a younger Bartlett in the AU where aliens invaded.

  3. Lee says:

    The manifestation of ‘Miracle Day’ is the best concept for an alien invention story I’ve ever come across. The first episode of this re-vamped Torchwood was excellent; but it’s been downhill ever since.

  4. Pingback: Index: Torchwood | In Search of the Happiness Max

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s